Gr 8 Up—To Do was Stein's second children's book, published posthumously by Yale University in 1957. This new edition, released 65 years after her death, is accompanied by Potter's folk-art-style illustrations. The full-page artwork is charming, but the book will still find limited appeal among children. Suitable for academic or large metropolitan libraries, it is an A-to-Z compilation of birthday stories. The dense text can be challenging to follow: "And so they all went to sleep and it was F. Yes it was it was F. But nobody must forget not yet that F follows E. Francis, Fatty, Fred and Fanny." So it goes for 127 pages. Some of the stories were written with dark humor, like "Q," which features a cannibalistic rabbit. Most will leave readers scratching their heads. Certainly a work by a major American-born author is important, but To Do is best left on the shelves of research libraries.—Roxanne Burg, Orange County Public Library, CA
A manuscript previously published in scholarly collections of Stein's works is illustrated for a young audience (ostensibly). Stein's prose is magnificent to read aloud, and Potter's paintings successfully merge the abstract with the concrete. Still, the length of the book and the lack of narrative will hinder all but the most determined readers from following through.
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!