Gr 6–8—In 1862, 12-year-old P. K. Pinkerton discovers his foster parents murdered in their cabin. He feels no grief, apparently because he is autistic. The killer is ruthless desperado Whittlin Walt, who then pursues P. K. for his valuable mine claim. The boy flees to lawless Virginia City, Nevada Territory, to register his document. There he meets many motley citizens of the Wild West town: Belle Donne, a Soiled Dove who robs him; Samuel Clemens, a newspaperman who quotes Mark Twain; Grafton T. Brown, an African American artist; "Chinamen"; and Jace, a cardsharp who teaches grateful P. K. to decipher body language. The denouement takes place in a mine shaft amid a startling revelation. This book is more an adventure story than a mystery. While it contains appealing elements and an intriguing premise, it seems flat at times because P. K. does not comprehend emotion. His oblique references to that fact may confuse readers. Numerous characters and scenarios have him bouncing from saloon to shop without much connection. The biggest concern, however, is audience. Descriptions of prostitutes and desire, while not detailed, indicate older readers. P. K.'s age and innocent manner suggest an elementary audience, but the mature concepts make that problematic. Middle schoolers may wish to try Jean Ferris's Much Ado About Grubstake (Harcourt, 2006).—
Caitlin Augusta, Stratford Library Association, CTP.K.'s story opens when a gang of outlaws kills his foster parents and he escapes with his "Destiny," which turns out to be a deed to a mine worth millions. P.K. has trouble showing emotion and reading people, a dual problem that keeps getting him in trouble. The strongly voiced account succeeds as a rousing adventure that promises more action in a future installment. Glos.
"My name is P.K. Pinkerton and before this day is over I will be dead." And so begins a bang-up series starter, told in flashback by young P.K. Pinkerton. P.K.’s story opens when a gang of outlaws, dressed as Indians, kills his foster parents. P.K., who is half Sioux, escapes, but not without a medicine bag his foster ma instructs him to take before she dies and which holds his "Destiny." He jumps a stagecoach and heads for Virginia City, which is, according to P.K.’s foster pa, "the vilest place on earth," populated with all kinds of evil folk: "Desperados, Gamblers, Gunmen & Lawyers." Although he’s whip smart, the counterbalance to P.K.’s intelligence is the "Thorn in his side": i.e., he seems to have what we would now call Asperger’s. He has trouble showing emotion and reading people, a dual problem that keeps getting him in trouble. On his arrival, P.K. meets one Belle Donne, a prostitute with a heart of coal; after what appears to be an act of kindness she robs him of his Destiny. That Destiny is the deed to a mine worth millions, according to newspaperman Sam Clemens. Although the conceit of the story (that P.K. scribbled down this well-paced narrative during a few hours hiding out in a mine shaft) doesn’t quite work, his strongly voiced account succeeds as a rousing adventure that promises more action in another installment just around the corner. Appended with a glossary of nineteenth-century terms. betty carter
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!