Gr 5–8—Boyne, much like in
The Boy in the Striped Pajamas (David Fickling Books, 2006), takes readers into the throes of war as seen through the eyes of a child. Alfie will always remember the day the fighting started because it was his fifth birthday, the day his whole world changed, the 28th of July 1914. Alfie's father, a milkman in their London neighborhood, enlists believing "the war will be over by Christmas." Four years later, Alfie is nine and the war rages on. Alfie begins shining shoes to help support his mother who works multiple jobs. Alfie believes his father to be dead until one day, while working, he discovers him in a hospital nearby. Sadly, the reunion is not the happy one Alfie expects. This is an excellent and approachable introduction to the traumas of war. All the characters are well developed and multilayered. Their thoughts and actions are authentic to the time and Alfie is no exception. His youth will not deter older readers since much of what is happening around him is so vivid. Detailed descriptions of character and place take readers into the heart of wartime Europe. There are some outlandish moments, including a scene with the Prime Minister, but this does not detract from the story or seem too incredible within the plot. This is not simply a book about the horrors of shellshock but also a comprehensive depiction of many different aspects of life during the World War I. Artwork not available at time of review.—
Kristyn Dorfman, The Packer Collegiate Institute, Brooklyn, NYFour years ago, nine-year-old Alfie Summerfield's dad, Georgie, went off to fight in WWI. For a while, letters from Georgie came regularly. Then they stopped altogether. Now Alfie (accidentally) learns that Georgie is in a nearby hospital, suffering from shell-shock. The third-person limited narration keeps readers experiencing events solely from Alfie's intelligent but childlike point of view.
Nine-year-old Alfie Summerfield's milkman dad, Georgie, went away four years ago, one of the first men on respectable Damley Road to sign up to fight in WWI. Since then, Alfie's life has changed drastically: his mum now works all hours as a nurse; his best friend Kalena Janácek and her sweet shop-owner father are gone, interned as spies; school is optional, and most days he skips it in favor of shining shoes at King's Cross Station. For a while, letters from Georgie had come regularly -- first cheery and upbeat and later filled with horror and misery. Then they stop altogether. Alfie doesn't believe his mother's explanation that Georgie is on a "secret mission for the government," but it's not until he accidentally glimpses some papers belonging to one of his customers that he learns Georgie is in a nearby hospital, suffering from shell-shock. As in previous Boyne work (The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, rev. 9/06), unlikely encounters and occurrences abound (Alfie not only meets the prime minister but manages to both locate and rescue his father). While the plot is a veritable alphabet soup of WWI British home-front tropes -- from the belief that it would "all be over by Christmas" to mob attacks on foreigners to the white feathers (for cowardice) handed out to unenlisted men -- it's made palatable by the third-person limited narration, which keeps readers experiencing events solely from Alfie's intelligent but childlike point of view. And the portraits drawn of the shell-shocked soldiers are heartbreaking. martha v. parravano
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!