PreS-Gr 2–Rohmann’s relief prints bring an exuberant humor to Fleming’s rhythmic read-aloud. When an elastic-looking frog falls into a deep hole (“Ribbit-oops!”), a timid mouse, lugubrious loris, resourceful sun bear, and jaunty monkey all tumble down after him during unsuccessful rescue attempts. Fleming’s bouncing rhymes and repeated lines–set in comfortably large, rounded text–entice readers into an enjoyable delivery complete with snarled sound effects and onomatopoeic exclamations. The repetitive “Oh, no!” allows listeners to join in with the engaging text as the animals face a lurking tiger eager to snack on the helpless group. Rohmann knows to leave swathes of open space in his full-spread illustrations, focusing attention on his expressive, energetic animals in their vibrant safari palette of bright browns, tans, and greens. In a satisfying conclusion, the refrain returns as the tiger, now stuck in the hole, asks the released animals if they will help him clamber out. Oh, no!
For her cumulative tale about animals falling into a hole, Fleming adopts the dancing cadence of "Frog Went a-Courting," punctuates each verse with a chime-in phrase, and concludes it with a repeated "Oh, No!": "Frog fell into a deep, deep hole. / Ribbit-oops! Ribbit-oops!...Frog fell into such a deep hole, / he couldn’t get out to save his soul. / Croaked Frog, ‘Help! Help! I can’t get out!’ / Oh, No!" So it goes with Mouse, Loris, and more, until Tiger -- who’s been lurking nearby all along -- threatens to "help [them] out." Fortunately, Elephant shows up to save the others while Tiger falls into his own trap -- at least until the escapees are safely out of sight. Rohmann’s energetic relief prints show the animals’ tumbles into that deep, dark, curvilinear hole from a variety of perspectives, further propelling the comic action, while a simply delineated bamboo grove forms an effective backdrop. Like Rohmann’s 2003 Caldecott winner My Friend Rabbit, this has all the marks of a soon-to-be-memorized favorite. joanna rudge long
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!