Gr 8 Up—Inspired by the author's personal experiences with bullying, this novel encourages readers to "never, ever give up." Noelle's life is bad; her mother drinks and her neglect goes unchecked. The teen eats mustard and mayonnaise sandwiches for lunch, and the smell from her unwashed clothes earns her the nickname "Rotten Egg." Her position as coeditor of the school literary magazine and the company of her science teacher and friends help alleviate her misery. Noelle eventually begins to accept aid from the people who care about her. When incredibly cute Julian shows interest, Noelle has to find the courage to change her life. This includes ending a destructive relationship and opening up about what she endures at home. When the school social worker brings Noelle's mother in for questioning, the story begins to fall apart. The woman hints at remorse, yet remains deranged. The friends take over, supplying Noelle with all she needs, including clean clothes, food, and love. It's not a horrible ending, only one that might seem illusionary to students enduring bullying and abuse in real life. Colasanti's mission to help victims and encourage teens to make a positive difference in the world is clear from her letter to readers and the back matter, which includes a list of resources. This novel could be recommended to those who enjoyed Sonya Sones's What My Mother Doesn't Know (S & S, 2001) or Courtney Summers's Some Girls Are (St. Martin's, 2010).—Pamela Schembri, Newburgh Enlarged City Schools, NY
Noelle is poor, ostracized, and constantly bullied. Her mother is neglectful at best, and her supposed boyfriend refuses to be seen with her in public. When another bullied classmate commits suicide, Noelle finally finds the strength to advocate for herself. Unfortunately, this well-intended novel is poorly developed and doesn't rise above its anti-bullying message.
Noelle’s situation—the bullying she endures at school, the neglect she endures at home—makes her easy to care for, but it’s her clear-eyed narration and fierce determination to succeed and help others (she keeps a list in her binder called “Things to Remember When I’m a Teacher”) that make her easy to admire. Susane Colasanti takes readers deep into Noelle’s world, where a constant onslaught of challenges, big and small, comes from neglect and poverty. “I have Spanish right before lunch,” Noelle says. “My stomach always growls in class. When I feel a growl coming on, I’ll do something like cough or flip pages loudly to hide it. It’s so obvious what I’m doing, though.” Bright spots in Noelle’s life prevent the novel from feeling too heavy or despairing. A generous and loyal best friend, a caring teacher, and a thoughtful boy friend (who might one day become a boyfriend) provide a range of feelings and make the story believable. When readers first meet Noelle, her top priority is surviving high school. But the real lesson Colasanti is after is that Noelle doesn’t have to wait until graduation to start living. Over the course of Keep Holding On, Noelle learns to stand up for herself, make changes in the present tense, and claim her right to happiness.
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!