PreS-Gr 2—This book's cover art, depicting a child thinking about a dog, is indicative of this playful journey through the animal world. Swenson asks readers to imagine themselves as several different animals, including a dinosaur, a bug, and a bird, and decide how that creature's qualities would appeal to them. For instance, would the child like to be a "sea-sparkler; ocean-swimming, coral-peeker;/wave-jumping,/flash-of-color; toe-nibbler,/faster-than-the-big-fish sort of fish?" After this fun list of descriptive words, Swenson comes back to another specific quality of that animal: "Would you splash in the surf? Some fish do." These lists help emphasize the diversity of species and the many ways these animals engage with their environment. The text has a rhyming, sing-song quality that makes it a great match for preschool storytimes. Raschka brings movement, energy, and personality to his vibrantly colored art. With just a few strokes, he makes a hissing cat puff up in anger at a nearby dog, ferocious and threatening. Readers can act out the characteristics of that cat or fish as the story is read. However, this could also be used in a classroom, both as a model for creative writing or as a beginning point for expanded study on a given species. A fun way to get readers to use their imaginations in the natural world.—
Susan E. Murray, formerly at Glendale Public Library, AZ"If you were a dog, would you be a speedy-quick, / Lickety-sloppidy, / scavenge-the-garbage, / frisbee-catching, / hot-dog stealing, / pillow-hogging, / best-friend-ever sort of dog?" After dog comes cat, fish, bug, and so on. The playful direct-address text maintains a pattern, but specifics are gleefully unpredictable. In a pleasing twist, the final animals introduced are dinosaurs. Expressive, gestural art captures the animals' movements.
Not so much a story as an imaginative survey of creatures great and small, this book presents a variety of animals just being themselves. Swenson's playful direct-address text is chock-full of sound effects ("Arrrrrrooooooooooooo!") and rollicking rhythms that beg to be read aloud. Opening lines ask, "If you were a dog, would you be a speedy-quick, / Lickety-sloppidy, / scavenge-the-garbage, / frisbee-catching, / hot-dog stealing, / pillow-hogging, / best-friend-ever sort of dog? / Would you howl at the moon? / Some dogs do." After dog comes cat, fish, bird, bug, and so on. Swenson sticks to a pattern ("If you were a… / Some…do"), but specifics are gleefully unpredictable. In a pleasing twist, the final animals introduced are dinosaurs. Raschka's talent at capturing animals' movements through expressive, gestural art is in full effect. Panel illustrations show individual creatures doing their things, culminating, in each case, with an expansive double-page spread. Book's end brings kids back to the human realm, acknowledging that they are not dogs or cats or dinosaurs, but squarely affirming that being a kid "is the very best sort of thing to be." So if you were a librarian (or a teacher or a parent) looking for a good read-aloud, what sort of book would you choose? This one's a good bet. megan dowd lambert
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!