Columbus Day

K-Gr 4—Why do we celebrate Columbus Day? Was Christopher Columbus an explorer or an exploiter? This DVD attempts to show both sides of the story. Using the construct of a community center, the leader gently encourages discussion comparing what children know about the holiday and what may not be true. Certainly, the New World was new to the Europeans who planted their flag on what is now part of the Bahamas. Yet, the land was already inhabited by the Taino Indians. Columbus did not recognize the Taino as a free, independent people, and used them as slaves to dig for gold. Their culture was decimated, and many died from European diseases. Should we be celebrating this holiday? Both the Native and European viewpoints are clearly examined, making children aware that there is more than one perspective when considering historical events. A descendent of the Taino people speaks about his ancestors' suffering, while it is explained that Columbus did open the door for other explorers and settlers. The online teacher's guide offers information about a rich collection of print and Internet resources to continue the debate. Using bright cartoons and clever graphics, this film offers different perspectives on Columbus's explorations and the celebration of the holiday in his honor.—Lonna Pierce, MacArthur Elementary School, Binghamton, NY