Gr 9 Up—More than 170 articles and 118 sidebars by 69 specialists cover a huge swath of the experience of Asian Americans. These volumes attempt an overview of religion, food, the arts, education, sports, family, gender, tradition, and history. There are many black-and-white photos and a "Guide to Related Topics" but no chronology. Besides "see-also" and further reading listings after each article, a nine-page bibliography lists recommended resources (with a few DVDs but no websites). A pertinent introduction clarifies the category "Asian American," including mixed-race and South Asian Americans, and notes especially those historically underrepresented (for instance, Cambodians, Hmong, and Indonesians). Transliterated words are defined parenthetically on their first use in an article, but there is no general glossary. The index misses references inside articles. Some Canadians and Britons are included, but others are not. Ashima Shiraishi, Kent Nagano, Amit Majmudar, George Nakashima, Ved Mehta, Seiji Ozawa, Sarah Sze, and Eileen Chang, among others, ought to be included in a future edition. Redundancy, graceless writing, and copy flaws weaken the work's authority.
VERDICT Secondary students in social studies and multicultural courses will find these volumes a starting point, offering more scope and graphics than Xiaojian Zhao and Edward J.W. Park's Asian Americans: An Encyclopedia of Social, Cultural, Economic, and Political History. Although more recent, this set does not necessarily supersede Huping Ling and Allan Austin's Asian American History and Culture, which is superior in expression, depth, and organization.
Be the first reader to comment.
Comment Policy:
Comment should not be empty !!!