The Publishing Perspective on Diversity

The book community reflects on the issues, successes, and trends in addressing diversity in books for children and YA.

SLJ Diversity -web_eyebrow

Adrea Davis Pinkney Photo by Christine Simmons

Adrea Davis Pinkney
Photo by Christine Simmons

“If you look at the United States of America now, multiculturalism is the mainstream,” says Andrea Davis Pinkney (pictured), a vice president and executive editor at Scholastic and an African American author of children’s books. However, “we are not reflecting this nation.”

Phoebe Yeh agrees. “There’s work to be done,” says the vice president and publisher of Crown Books for Young Readers, a division of Random House Children’s Books.

“We all need to try harder,” also affirms Angus Killick, vice president and associate publisher of the Macmillan Children’s Publishing Group.

These three are among a number of publishing professionals interviewed by School Library Journal who agreed that more books for young people must feature characters who represent the diversity of the U.S. population. They are also among those in the field who are addressing the gap.

Myth: ‘These books don’t sell’

“There’s a strong Mexican American middle class that buys books,” says Bobby Byrd, copublisher of Cinco Puntos Press, located on the Texas-Mexico border. “There are close to 40 million Latinos in the U.S. That’s a huge market. The book industry has been slow to respond.”

Titles that could be seen as strictly niche have deeper market reach. Christopher Johns, sales and marketing director for Tuttle Publishing, the largest English-language Asian publisher, says, “big box chains like Costco carry our books on Chinese New Year’s.” However, Tuttle’s audience—many of them second- and third-generation Asian Americans, as well as adoptive parents of Chinese kids, Johns says—purchase year round. “It’s not the first generation we sell a lot to,” Jones notes. “It’s the second and third generations.”

The track record of books with diverse characters help illuminate the sales potential. For example, the Lerner Publishing Group’s top-grossing picture book for the past five years has been Vaunda Micheaux Nelson’s Bad News for Outlaws (2009), a Coretta Scott King Award-winning story, says Andrew Karre, an editorial director at Lerner.

Groundwood Books has sold two million copies in its “Breadwinner” series by Deborah Ellis, about a girl in Afghanistan under the Taliban who dresses as a boy to support her family. It’s “a very universal story,” says Groundwood publisher Sheila Barry.

Saddleback Educational Publishing has sold more than a million copies in its 40-title “Urban Underground” series, about African American and Latino teens. And Cinco Puntos has sold more than 600,000 copies of Joe Hayes’s La Llorona: The Weeping Woman (1987), a retelling of a popular Mexican legend.

Successful sales aside, “When you’re dealing with under served communities, diverse consumers, there’s more of a pass-along that is not always quantifiable,” says Pinkney. “We have to really redefine what a ‘successful’ book is.”


Malinda Lo, author of the YA sci-fi thrillers Adaptation and Inheritance (both Little, Brown, 2012 and 2013), says that the imbalance in publishing reflects a society that “privileges whiteness.”

The color bias, Lo says, is “expressed in picture books that show white people much more often than children of color. It’s expressed in overt racist comments on the Internet. It’s expressed in beliefs such as the model minority myth about Asian Americans.” She adds, “The assumption that people of color might not have money to buy books is part of institutional racism.”

But diversity in the field may be more widespread than it appears, says Tim McHugh, co-owner of Saddleback, specializing in books for struggling learners. A well-circulated study from the Cooperative Children’s Book Center (CCBC) showed that just 93 of the 3,200 children’s books published in 2013 were about African Americans. But those numbers only reflect books that trade publishers sent to CCBC, as the organization’s director, K. T. Horning, author of “Still an All-White World?” (pp. 18–21), confirmed.

“Nothing sinister here, but small and medium publishers are left out” of the CCBC study, McHugh says. “Perhaps we should be celebrated for publishing more than the large publishing houses.”

The balance is “much better than when I was a child,” says Alvina Ling, executive editorial director at Little, Brown Books for Young Readers (Hachette), whose award-winning titles include Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian (2007), which has sold over 1.5 million copies, and Grace Lin’s Where the Mountain Meets the Moon (2009). “Growing up, I was very hungry to see myself in the books I was reading,” adds Ling, also a founding member of the Children’s Book Council diversity committee, created to expand the range of voices and experiences in children’s literature. “Now there are so many great books out there for diverse children.” But, “We have far to go.”

The importance of visibility

Awards propel sales and help increase consumer awareness of diverse titles. “The books that have gotten awards are the ones that are going to get to stay in print,” says Yeh, referring to honors such as the Coretta Scott King Award, granted to African American authors and illustrators; the Pura Belpré Award, given to Latino/Latina authors and illustrators; and the Stonewall Book Award–Mike Morgan and Larry Romans Children’s and Young Adult Literature Award, for LGBTQ titles. Books that receive Newbery or Caldecott recognition in addition to the more culturally specific awards fare the best by far, in terms of sales. Christopher Paul Curtis’s Bud, Not Buddy (Delacorte, 1999) which received the Newbery and Coretta Scott King awards in 2000, has sold 2.4 million copies, while Curtis’s The Watsons Go to Birmingham—1963 (Delacorte, 1995), which received a Newbery Honor and the Coretta Scott King Award in 1996, sold 2.6 million, says Dominique Cimina, a spokesperson for Random House Children’s Books.

Unlike awards such as the Coretta Scott King and the Pure Belpré, the Newbery and Caldecott criteria do not require committee members to consider the cultural background of the authors and illustrators, or the inclusion of multicultural themes. Still, books featuring nonwhite or differently abled characters occasionally receive recognition. Kiera Parrott, SLJ reviews editor, surveyed the last 10 years of Newbery and Caldecott medal and honor books. She found that roughly 31 percent of Newbery award or honor books and 22.5 percent of Caldecott award or honor books center on diverse characters or themes. Still, these stats are far from being wholly representative of an increasingly multicultural country, Parrott says.

Another part of the visibility picture is that retailers tend to devote shelf space primarily to the “big five” trade publishers—Penguin Random, HarperCollins, Hachette, Macmillan, and Simon & Schuster—or they create special sections. Jason Low, publisher of Lee & Low Books, specializing in stories that children of color can identify with, says, “bookstores that do stock diverse titles tend to segregate ethnic-themed books from other books.” He adds, “this makes discoverability difficult.”

Some unique avenues can lead to sales. For example, Abrams initially printed 15,000 copies of Boni Ashburn’s I Had a Favorite Dress (2011), picturing the African American girl protagonist on the cover. It sold nearly 40,000 copies, in part because the Anthropologie clothing store chain carried the book.

In another approach, reps from Free Spirit Publishing attend the African American Children’s Book Fair to raise awareness of their titles with characters of diverse backgrounds, ethnicities, and abilities/special needs, and participate in walks supporting autism causes.


Authors and authenticity

What makes for an authentic story? While some publishers want their authors to have firsthand experience of their subject matter, others maintain that this isn’t important. “Our authors live the lives they write about, or they witness them firsthand,” says McHugh. For example, Saddleback author Shannon Freeman, who is African American, teaches English in a Texas school with African American, Latino, and Vietnamese teens. Free Spirit, which has a diverse 44-member teen advisory board, recently published How to Talk to an Autistic Kid (2011) by Daniel Stefanski, himself a young man with autism.

Cinco Puntos tries to ensure that an author, illustrator, or both are of color, says Byrd. Tim Tingle and Jeanne Rorex Bridges, the author and illustrator of Crossing Bok Chitto (2006), an American Library Association Notable Children’s Book, are both Native American. “We’re interested in writers who speak of what they know,” says Byrd.

Many say that if a book feels true, it doesn’t matter who wrote it. “You don’t have to be a person of color to edit a book by or about a person of color,” says Yeh. “You need to get it.”

“Authenticity comes from the author’s pen,” says Pinkney.

“It’s important for people to be able to write books about whatever group they want,” says Calista Brill, senior editor at Macmillan’s First Second Books, which published Gene Luen Yang’s Printz Award-winning American Born Chinese (2006) and Boxers & Saints (2013). However, authors should “do a lot of careful research if it’s not their own personal experience.”

“Research is essential,” concurs Low. “It is also a must to find one or more outside readers or experts in the culture or topic being written about.”

Kelly Cunnane’s book Deep in the Sahara (Random, 2013), about a girl who wants to wear a head scarf, was written by a white woman who traveled to Mauritania. “We thought it was just a beautifully written story,” says Lee Wade, vice president and codirector of the Random House imprint Schwartz & Wade. Anne Schwartz, also vice president and codirector, asked an Iranian illustrator who wears a head scarf to create the art for the story.

The “Max Axiom” series (Capstone), starring a science superhero of color, has been produced over the years by authors and illustrators of different ethnicities, says Ashley Andersen Zantop, Capstone group publisher and general manager. Author Fran Manushkin, who is white, writes Capstone’s “Katie Woo” books, about an Asian American character inspired by her great-niece, whose father is of Chinese descent.

Regarding authors, “it isn’t enough to sit in your office and wait for what people send you,” says Groundwood’s Barry. “You have to make it a priority to go find them.”

Pigeonholing can also be an issue. “There’s the frustration of being an African American author and finding your pub dates are always going to be in February,” African American History Month, says literary agent Barry Goldblatt, whose client Angela Johnson is a three-time Coretta Scott King Award winner. “What I’m trying to do is to make [the field] feel welcoming for everyone.”

How do the decision-makers define “diversity?” Stories that go “beyond the white heterosexual middle class,” says Barry.

For Killick, “It centers on community. It could be ethnic, it could be religious, LGBTQ.”

Schwartz says, “We don’t try to define it. We just publish what we love.”

Springen_Karen_ContribKaren Springen’s article “SisOps,” about tech programs for girls, appears on page 36 of this issue.

Comment Policy:
  • Be respectful, and do not attack the author, people mentioned in the article, or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  • Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  • Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.
  • Comments may be republished in print, online, or other forms of media.
  • If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.

Robbin Miller

Hi, I have written my first picture book called "EJ's Playgroup." It is about my son, EJ, who attended a structured playgroup at an Early Intervention Site when he was five months old with children with/out disabilities. The story is about EJ meeting a new friend, Lewis, who was born with a cleft palate when he was born in China. EJ (now 15 months old) wants to show Lewis (twelve months old) how much fun playgroup can be to meet new friends. My characters are all from diverse backgrounds. The theme of the book is "Children are children who want to have fun together." In addition, I also written my second picture book entitled "Welcome to Davis Playground." It is about a ten year old boy named Max who is a wheelchair user who is not able to join his two best friends in a new playground in his community. Sophia and Demitris are harassed by their able-bodied peers to exclude Max from playing in the inaccessible playground. The picture book's theme is about the test of friendship between Max and his best friends as they cope with the peer pressure from the other children. This book is also based upon a true story in my town where the community followed popular thinking to build inaccessible playgrounds on public property. I welcome your opinion and any interest from a literary agent or book publisher My picture book would fit the request, "WeNeedDiverseBooks" that represents all cultures with/out disabilities. Robbin Miller

Posted : Jun 14, 2014 05:32

KT Horning

I would like to correct something Tim McHugh was quoted as saying about the CCBC's statistics. While it's true we don't get absolutely everything published each year (and we are up front about that on our website where the statistics appear), it is simply not true that we ignore books from small and medium publishers. In fact, the CCBC has been a vocal proponent and supporter of small, alternative presses since 1980 , when we first started to identify and actively collect books from these publishers. Before the internet era, we published a directory of small independent publishers aimed at helping teachers and librarians find and purchase the books. Cheryl Hudson from Just Us Books and Jason Low from Lee & Low can vouch for me on this. We knew these companies when they were just getting started. We have had a special interest in multicultural literature, especially those published by small presses owned and operated by people of color, which in some cases have only ever published one children's book. In our collection, you will find first editions of books from Children's Book Press, Black Butterfly, Arte Publico, Just Us Books, Lee & Low, Groundwood, Pemmican, Rough Rock Press, and Zamani, to name just a few. All of there books have been counted over the years in our statistics. In fact, it's fascinating to see just how many of the multicultural books have been published by small presses. For example, seven of the eight books Debbie Reese mentioned above were from small presses. We document whatever we receive as review copies we get from publishers. Tim's company, Saddleback, has just discovered the CCBC and has started sending us review copies so from now on, Saddleback books will be included in the count. What is most often not included are the formula nonfiction books from presses like Chelsea House. While we get some of these series books, it is hard to convince these companies to send review copies because they are so rarely reviewed by the professional journals. We would love to get their books so we could include them. Many of them are excellent contributions to multicultural literature. I don't want readers to be left with the impression a that we pick and choose what to count, or that we snub small publishers. People who know us well and know our work already know this isn't true. And for any small publishers of multicultural books out there who don't know the CCBC, please contact us so we can include you.

Posted : May 08, 2014 07:30

Debbie Reese

I did an analysis of the fiction by/about American Indians on the CCBC list, focusing on US publishers. Of the 14 fiction/US publishers/by and about American Indians that I analyzed, eight are ones that I recommend based on my research on the ways that Native peoples are portrayed in children's and YA lit. I haven't yet looked at the other books on the list (published in Canada), but it is clear to me that small publishers are doing a better job at finding/publishing Native voices.

Posted : May 02, 2014 12:31

Bobby Byrd

Thank you, Debbie Springen, and right on, Debbie Reese!

Posted : May 06, 2014 12:54



We are currently offering this content for free. Sign up now to activate your personal profile, where you can save articles for future viewing