Google+

August 30, 2014

Subscribe to SLJ

‘Golden Domes’ Picture Book Causes Stir at Scholastic Book Fair

meinseattle Golden Domes Picture Book Causes Stir at Scholastic Book Fair

Hena Khan, author of Golden Domes and Silver Lanterns

A parent in Marietta, Georgia, has lodged a complaint with his local school board about the inclusion of Hena Khan’s picture book Golden Domes and Silver Lanterns: A Muslim Book of Colors (Chronicle, 2012) at his daughter’s Scholastic Book Fair on October 17. Thomas Prisock claims that the book is “an indoctrination of Muslim culture,” according to the The Marietta Daily Journal (MDJ).

Prisock’s daughter selected the colorful title from 3,000 available books at the fair, which was hosted by children’s publisher Scholastic and sponsored by the local Parent Teacher Association (PTA) at Dowell Elementary School. His wife purchased the book for about $5. Prisock told Fox News that he later returned to the fair and noticed a lack of representation from other religions.

“I know they are trying to do a good thing, this just struck me as wrong,” says Prisock in MDJ’s report. “That culture there doesn’t seem to have anything good coming out of it.”

However, Abi Nesmith, PTA president and parent of a fifth grader, counters that the school’s population—which includes Christians, Muslims, and Jews—was well reflected in the book fair’s diversity of offerings, according to MDJ’s report.

Golden Domes is not a stranger to controversy. Earlier this year, it was the focal point of a Twitter battle between middle-grade author Kate Messner and an unknown Twitter user. Messner had recommended the book on her social media account as a positive portrayal of Islam for young readers, when the user responded with inflammatory comments.

Author Khan tells School Library Journal that response for her book has been otherwise overwhelmingly positive, both before and after this event. “Booksellers, teachers, parents, media specialists—Muslims and non-Muslims—value my book and want to see more like it.”

hijab image 600x245 Golden Domes Picture Book Causes Stir at Scholastic Book Fair

A spread from Khan’s picture book, illustrated by Mehrdokht Amini.

“I found it very disheartening to hear that he returned the book after his own daughter selected it and his wife bought it,” Khan says. “Sadly, this incident is representative of the many actions that occur that are fueled by misconceptions, stereotypes, and ignorance. We have to educate our children and show them why we need to embrace diversity and tolerance.”

Ginee Seo, publisher at Chronicle Children’s Books, agrees.  “I’m really distressed that we still have to have conversations about diversity, and I say that as a first-generation Asian American. Let’s not forget that it was intolerance that got us to 9/11,” she tells SLJ. “I’m proud of the fact that we publish this book. It describes Islam in a beautiful, creative way. It doesn’t propagate anything but greater understanding.”

According to MDJ’s report, Doug Goodwin, a spokesman for the Cobb school district, says the district welcomes Scholastic book fairs in its schools “to promote literacy and foster a love for reading” and that the fairs offer “a wide variety of children’s literature.” Goodwin also notes in the report that if a parent objects to a book selection, the district’s Library Media Education department will “gladly assist them in selecting a replacement book.”

Prisock was eventually allowed to return the book to the fair. SLJ’s requests for comment to school officials were not returned.

As for Khan, she is currently working on several picture and middle-grade book projects. She adds, “Educating kids about different cultures is key to building tolerance and acceptance.”

Shelley Diaz About Shelley Diaz

Shelley M. Diaz (sdiaz@mediasourceinc.com) is Senior Editor of School Library Journal's Reviews. She recently received her MLIS in Public Librarianship with a Certificate in Children’s & YA Services from Queens College, and can be found on Twitter @sdiaz101.

Share

Comments

  1. it looks like a beautiful book. People need to chill out and allow their children to view differing cultures and ideas.

  2. Deborah Rogers says:

    I found this to be a beautiful book and put it on my list of books to order for the libaray. Our Scholastic book fair had books about Christmas- even one about the Nativity- and Hanukkah, so I did not see a lack of “balance.” We need books that feature ALL of our students in a positive light.

  3. Laura Harrison says:

    What a sad story! I feel terrible for the child. Returning this lovely book did not benefit his daughter in any possible way. In my opinion all he accomplished was disempowering her from having confidence in selecting a book for herself.

  4. Maureen Lein says:

    Sounds to me like the dad in this case is a racist

  5. Sarah Moukhliss says:

    This is a stunning book along with the simple, yet beautiful prose and amazing illustrations. I am sad that this book is receiving attention in this light.

  6. Beverley Graham says:

    This is how we end up with a racist culture. Children are not born hating the “Other” in our society. I wonder if the Dad read the book in question.

    If he had any reservations about the motive behind the book, he and his wife should have read the book with their daughter and discuss what they had in common with the characters in the book and what the differences were — without judgement. A teachable moment about how to be a good global citizen was lost there!

  7. I own this book and think it is beautiful. It presents colors from a cultural, not religious, viewpoint. If I told you the hijab is blue the the dome is gold the Quran is green, what have you learned about Islam? Nothing. No more than if I said the Bible is black. That tells you nothing about Christianity. This is about bigotry (and that man dominating his family by overriding their book choices), not an attempt at indoctrinating young children into Islam. I am not Moslem, have no Moslems in my family, don’t even have children. I bought the book because it was so charming and beautiful. Bigotry must be stopped at any level.

Comment Policy:
  1. Be respectful, and do not attack the author or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  2. Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  3. Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.

We are not able to monitor every comment that comes through (though some comments with links to multiple URLs are held for spam-check moderation by the system). If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.

We accept clean XHTML in comments, but don't overdo it and please limit the number of links submitted in your comment. For more info, see the full Terms of Use.

Speak Your Mind

*