"Selma": Accurate Enough? Questions about the film’s historical accuracy present a teachable moment.

Weighing in on the recent controversy over "Selma" and the ensuing Oscar fallout, author Elizabeth Partridge offers some ideas for engaging students in a discussion about historical accuracy, primary sources, and expert opinion.
  Freedom Marchers with Flags, 1965. Photo by Matt Heron

Freedom Marchers with Flags, 1965. Photo by Matt Heron

Film director Ava DuVernay kicked a sacred cow in the movie "Selma" with her portrayal of Martin Luther King, Jr. as the tough, demanding driver of the Voting Rights Act of 1965. Influential, well-connected people from Joseph Califano to Maureen Dowd have expressed their dismay at seeing President Lyndon Johnson depicted as the reluctant, recalcitrant president who had his arm twisted into compliance. Others have rushed to DuVernay's defense. The dialog between the two men is discomforting. In real life, King had the finesse of a black preacher born in the segregated South speaking to a white man. He was nuanced and respectful of the President: if not of the man, of the office. But no matter how you parse it, King and Johnson both wanted and needed the Voting Rights Act, and in their own way, worked together to achieve it. The whole controversy misses one of the most skillfully-done aspects of Selma. This is the 1965 voting rights marches seen through the eyes of 2014, the eyes of “Hands up, don’t shoot,” and “Black Lives Matter.” Right now, frustration and anger have a place at the rainbow table we insist is set equally for all Americans. Duvernay masterfully slips in 2014 reference points. Look at the protesters sitting in front of the Dallas County courthouse, fingers laced behind their heads, elbows jutting out. In 1965, people daisy-chained themselves together, crossing one arm over the other to hold hands with those on either side. “Hands up” would have been jarring. Those jutting elbows sneak up on you later, when you Google “Selma” and look at 50 year old black-and-white photographs. Or listen carefully to “Glory,” Common and John Legend’s Golden Globe-winning song: it begins as a swooping spiritual-turned-protest song, moves into rap, bringing us up to 2014 with the lyrics, before slipping back to protest song. Bobby Simmons, 17 Years Old, Marches for the Vote, 1965. Photo by Matt Herron www.takestockphotos.com

Bobby Simmons, 17 Years Old, Marches for the Vote, 1965. Photo by Matt Herron www.takestockphotos.com

The lyrics remind us that the rainbow promise hasn’t been delivered on: “That’s why Rosa sat on the bus/That’s why we walk through Ferguson with our hands up.” And the path forward: “It takes the wisdom of the elders and young people’s energy.” In the first heady moments of the film’s release, it looked like there might be a place at the table in Hollywood for Duvernay. Though the film has been nominated for an Oscar for Best Picture and Best Original Song, DuVernay was not nominated for Best Director. Hollywood is not ready for the edge in her voice, not ready for her insistence that we open our eyes and place our history in context. Interviewed on NPR's Fresh Air, DuVernay put it this way: "I'm just inviting people into this time and space—into the spirit of Selma in 1965—what it was, what it means now..." This film gives us the opportunity to work with students on historical accuracy, using primary sources and expert opinion. Here are a few good starting points. Have students locate primary source material on President Johnson and Martin Luther King, Jr.
  1. Martin Luther King, Jr.: Cornell University Library has compiled a terrific list of primary sources on King, as has The King Center.
  2. Lyndon Baines Johnson: the LBJ Library has compiled archival materials (videos, phone calls, historians debating) on the relationship between King and Johnson, and a long list of journal articles with opinions on the film. Full video and transcript of the "American Promise" speech by LBJ. All presidential photos on the site are in the public domain and can be freely copied and used.
Learn more about the five day march to Montgomery, covered in the film with archival footage.
  1. Read the article that appeared in the 1965 New Yorker, Letter from Selma, written by reporter Renata Adler. What do you learn about the young adults who marched that wasn't covered in the film?
Close read of visuals:
  1. Have students locate archival photos of the Selma protests. Compare them with stills from the film. How are they the same? How are they different?
  2. Check out the cover of the New Yorker, January 26, 2015. Who are the people portrayed on the cover? What point is the artist trying to make?

Discussion:

Although Selma is not a documentary film, it is a film about real people, in a real historical period. What is the difference between a documentary film and a dramatization?  What responsibility does the director, Ava DuVernay, have to historical accuracy?
Elizabeth Partridge is the author of Marching For Freedom: Walk Together Children and Don't You Get Weary (Viking Children's Books, 2009).
 
Comment Policy:
  • Be respectful, and do not attack the author, people mentioned in the article, or other commenters. Take on the idea, not the messenger.
  • Don't use obscene, profane, or vulgar language.
  • Stay on point. Comments that stray from the topic at hand may be deleted.
  • Comments may be republished in print, online, or other forms of media.
  • If you see something objectionable, please let us know. Once a comment has been flagged, a staff member will investigate.


Elizabeth Partridge`

Leda, These are truly beautiful photographs, and a wonderful primary historical document. This photograph by Morton Broffman http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/gathering-at-the-alabama-state-capitol-in-montgomery-to-news-photo/529424993 illustrates one of the points of historical accuracy I was fascinated by. Look at the hands. Where are they? How do people hold their hands during a protest in the movie "Selma"? Why do you think the director made this choice? Do you think this was a good decision by the director Ava DuVernay?

Posted : Feb 09, 2015 10:44


leda

Betsy has asked me to link to some photos of the Selma march taken by my beloved uncle, Morton Broffman, a professional photographer who often photographed Martin Luther King and others. You can see 50 of them here: http://www.gettyimages.com/asset-detail/gallery/event/531132603 and some here: http://mortonbroffman.com/mainpages/civilrights.htm My uncle died too young of ALS in 1992. One is mislabeled, probably by Getty. Near the end, James Farmer is actually James Forman.

Posted : Feb 09, 2015 02:43

leda

That should be Foreman, not Forman. Sorry.

Posted : Feb 09, 2015 02:43


Ed Sullivan

After having students look at the momentous events of 50 years ago, have them examine some troubling recent history. What is noticeably absent in these discussions of the film Selma and Voting Rights Act of 1965 is the tragic gutting of that legislation by the United States Supreme Court a little over two years ago in a 5-4 decision. That decision was and is a spit on the grave of all the brave souls murdered in the cause of Civil Rights, a spit in the face of every person beaten and jailed in the marches and protests. One of those five members of the Supreme Court who voted to gut the Voting Rights Acts is an African American, Clarence Thomas, the inexplicable choice to succeed the great Thurgood Marshall. The five men responsible for this travesty have minds rooted in a profound ignorance of reality, an absurd assumption that the United States have advanced beyond the need for such laws. That's recent history students need to know and discuss.

Posted : Jan 30, 2015 01:56

Kathy Ishizuka

Indeed, you raise a critical point, Ed. Tapping Betsy Partridge for comment here.

Posted : Jan 30, 2015 01:56

Elizabeth Partridge

Ed, You bring up a really important point: the critical link between past and present. A great resource is the NAACP website, http://www.naacpldf.org/ They actively are pursuing the question: will marginalized groups right to vote be honored? I also follow Sherrillyn Ifill on twitter, @Sifill_LDF. In case her name rings a bell, she and Gwen Ifill are cousins. Two powerhouses.

Posted : Jan 30, 2015 01:56

Elizabeth Partridge

The Library of Congress has posted two interesting teaching resources for Selma. http://blogs.loc.gov/teachers/2015/02/teaching-selma-a-civil-rights-struggle-captured-in-primary-sources/ http://blogs.loc.gov/teachers/2015/02/teaching-selma-remembrances-and-memorials/

Posted : Jan 30, 2015 01:56


RELATED 

TOP STORIES

LIBRARY EDUCATION

Kids are using VR to explore worlds and create new ones

COMMUNITY FORM

Kids are using VR to explore worlds and create new ones

COLLECTION DEVELOPMENT

Kids are using VR to explore worlds and create new ones

Get connected. Join our global community of more than 200,000 librarians and educators.

Get access to 6000+ annual reviews of books, databases, and more

As low as $12/month